The short answer
Yes: under OPM’s rules in 5 CFR part 300, subpart D, an agency may use a commercial recruiting firm when its head or a designee finds that well-qualified candidates are in short supply or would not otherwise be available, the vacancy notice has gone to the State Employment Service and OPM, and the agency keeps recruiting on its own. What the rules forbid is a firm that charges the people it refers: under 5 CFR 300.404, an agency may not consider a candidate who has paid, or is expected to pay, the firm any fee. Applicants a firm finds are then rated and appointed through the agency’s regular procedures, veterans’ preference included.
- open federal roles
- 19,373
- open state roles competing for the same people
- 24,871
When an agency may use a firm
The rules call an outside recruiter a commercial recruiting firm: a profit-making business that, by contract, supplies candidates for specific federal vacancies, to requirements the agency sets. A nonprofit employment service, such as one run by a professional society, is treated the same way.
They cover positions in the competitive service, the excepted service under Schedules A, B and C, and the Senior Executive Service. For any of them, 5 CFR 300.403 lets an agency use a firm when three things are true:
- The agency head or a designee decides that a firm is likely to provide well-qualified candidates who would otherwise not be available, or that well-qualified candidates are in short supply.
- The agency has sent its vacancy notices to the appropriate State Employment Service and OPM offices.
- The agency keeps up its own recruiting while the firm works.
Write the first decision down. It is the reason the agency is paying for help, and the records rule below asks for it.
The fee rule: the candidate never pays
5 CFR 300.404 is the rule most often quoted as a ban. It bars agencies from using firms that charge fees to the people they refer, and it bars an agency from considering any candidate who has paid, or is expected to pay, a fee to the firm that referred them. The one exception is a registration fee a professional organization’s nonprofit service charges whether or not the person is referred or placed.
The rule follows a criminal statute. 18 U.S.C. 211 makes it a crime to take anything of value for helping a person get a federal job by referring their name to an agency, except for services an employment agency renders at the written request of an executive department or agency. Under 5 CFR 300.405, the agency’s contract with the firm is that written request.
So the firm is paid by the agency, under contract, and by nobody else. Before you sign, ask every firm in writing whether it charges candidates anything, for registration, placement or anything else.
What the contract must say
5 CFR 300.405 requires a written contract awarded under the Federal Acquisition Regulation. It must state the qualification requirements for the positions, and it must commit the firm to four things:
- Screen candidates only against the basic qualification requirements the agency set in the contract, and refer every candidate who appears to meet them.
- Refer only people from whom it has accepted no fee, other than the registration fee above.
- Never imply that it is the only or the main way into federal employment, or into your agency.
- Recruit and refer in line with merit principles and equal opportunity laws.
Paying by purchase card does not remove the need for a written agreement with those terms. If the purchase fits under the $15,000 micro-purchase threshold, ask your contracting office how a card purchase is documented, and read can a federal agency buy recruiting on a purchase card? for the buying rules.
What stays with the agency
A firm is an additional source of applicants, and nothing more. 5 CFR 300.406 says that once recruited, applicants are evaluated and appointed through regular civil service procedures: competitive procedures for a competitive service position, the appointing authority and part 302 for an excepted one, and the merit staffing process of 5 U.S.C. 3393 for a career Senior Executive Service appointment.
The same section requires three things of the agency:
- Make known that people may apply to the government directly and need not go through the firm.
- Give the same consideration to people who applied directly as to people the firm referred.
- Follow every requirement for appointment, including veterans’ preference where it applies.
Keep records. 5 CFR 300.407 asks agencies to keep what they need to show that using a firm is cost effective and broke no merit system principle, and to report on it when OPM asks. Under 300.408, OPM may order corrective action when an agency does not comply.
State and local agencies
Subpart D governs federal positions only. A state, county or city agency follows its own civil service rules and its own procurement code, and many of them use recruiting firms for hard-to-fill and senior roles. Ask your HR office which rules apply before you compare firms, and how its procurement office buys professional services.
For what drives a firm’s fee and how to compare written quotes, read how much a government recruiting firm costs.
How Ayla works within these rules
Ayla is a recruiting firm and a government hiring data platform. Its recruiting is paid by the hiring office, as a placement fee when you hire, quoted per role in writing after a free market brief, and it charges candidates nothing to be found or referred.
For a federal role, our recruiters bring applicants to your announcement, each with the reasons, and your HR office rates them, applies veterans’ preference and selects. Ayla sends a written quote and a W-9 on request, and takes a purchase card or a purchase order. See recruiting for agencies for how a role runs from first brief to selection.
Common questions.
- Is it legal for a federal agency to pay a recruiting firm?
- Yes, under 5 CFR part 300, subpart D, when well-qualified candidates are in short supply or would not otherwise be available, the vacancy notice has gone to the State Employment Service and OPM, and the agency keeps recruiting itself. The agency pays the firm under a written contract, and the candidate never pays it.
- Can an agency consider a candidate who paid a recruiter?
- No. Under 5 CFR 300.404, an agency may not consider a candidate referred by a firm if the candidate has paid, or is expected to pay, the firm any fee, apart from a professional organization’s registration fee charged whether or not the person is placed.
- Does veterans’ preference still apply to applicants a firm finds?
- Yes. Under 5 CFR 300.406 they are rated and appointed through the agency’s regular procedures, and the agency must follow every appointment requirement, veterans’ preference included.